Main menu:

Recent posts




To help keep HP running


Or make a one-off donation:

What’s wrong with Chuck Hagel?

This is a cross-post from Marc Goldberg

If all the speculation is to be believed President Obama is likely to appoint former US Senator Chuck Hagel as his next Secretary of Defense. Although this is still just speculation it is being reported in just about every media outlet and has caused more than a little controversy among the pro-Israel lobby.

Hagel is certainly a man who has spoken his mind over the years. He voted yes on the war on Iraq but very quickly changed his tune and in 2007 said the following; ”People say we’re not fighting for oil. Of course we are,” while becoming highly critical of the war.

He is reported to be sceptical of the value of sanctions against Iran in forcing the Islamic regime to give up their nuclear program and is also reported to be anti Israel to the point where Abe Foxman, the head of the Anti Defamation League commented of the nomination that; “At the very least it’s of concern to the American Jewish community, at the very most, it’s very troubling,”

After taking a good long look at this guy I really like him.

Hagel has a long and distinguished career in business and in politics and an incredibly impressive Vietnam War record where he attained the rank of Sergeant and earned Vietnamese Cross of Gallantry, two Purple Hearts, Army Commendation Medal, and the Combat Infantryman Badge. Not bad for a year’s work! It is perhaps because of his experiences in Vietnam that Chuck became such an ardent critic of the military involvement in Iraq as well as the way that he views other conflicts around the world.

As well as being a self made millionaire he often voted against Republican Party lines despite being a Republican Senator, he has said that ”I took an oath of office to the Constitution, I didn’t take an oath of office to my party or my president.” Here is a man who clearly works according to his conscience rather than merely blowing with the prevailing wind. He must have known that his stance on many issues would have gotten him into some deep water but he took those positions anyway and that is to be respected.

Let’s take a closer look at some of the statements he has made about Israel that have made him such a controversial choice, here’s one reported in Politico;

“The political reality is … that the Jewish lobby intimidates a lot of people up here,” Hagel told former Mideast peace negotiator Aaron David Miller in a 2006 interview. “I have always argued against some of the dumb things they do because I don’t think it’s in the interest of Israel. I just don’t think it’s smart for Israel.”

His use of the term ‘Jewish lobby’ instead of ‘Israel lobby’ got a lot of folks in Washington DC upset. It has not gotten me upset, in fact I hear people doing it all of the time, more importantly I agree with the substance of his argument. I also think that the government does a lot of really dumb things that are actually against our own national interest and I want there to be someone in Washington DC who’s prepared to actually tell them that rather than live in fear of the the Pro Israel lobby attacking them.

Another controversial statement he has made was to say “I am not an Israeli Senator, I am a United States senator”, I am not quite sure who can attack him for saying that, the man spoke an obvious truth!

The controversy over Hagel seems to stem not from the statements he has made or even the policies that he supports but from the fact that people have expectations that the next US Secretary for Defense should be more hardline than most Israelis are when it comes to the Middle East. Of course we want the man to take the job not to hate us and to positively work against the State of Israel but there simply isn’t anything in the man’s actions or words over the course of a very long career to make anyone think that he would.

What we can expect is a man who is prepared to stand up and speak his mind and as far as I’m concerned it won’t come a moment too soon!